My view

When Christmas and Hanukkah meet

A season of shared light

By MICHAEL KOSSOVE
Posted 12/16/25

In December, the world seems to glow a little brighter. Streets sparkle with colored lights, homes shimmer with candles in windows, and a spirit of warmth spreads across communities. It is the season …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in
My view

When Christmas and Hanukkah meet

A season of shared light

Posted

In December, the world seems to glow a little brighter. Streets sparkle with colored lights, homes shimmer with candles in windows, and a spirit of warmth spreads across communities. It is the season when Christians and Jews often celebrate their most meaningful holidays; Christmas and Hanukkah sometimes even overlap on the calendar. Though their origins and religious meanings differ, both holidays share common themes: light in darkness, hope against despair, generosity, family and food.

These twin celebrations, one commemorating the birth of Jesus Christ, the other the rededication of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem, illustrate how faith traditions, while distinct, often converge in their messages of renewal and joy.

Hanukkah, the Jewish Festival of Lights, commemorates the miracle that followed the Maccabean revolt in the second century BCE. After the Jewish people reclaimed their temple from the Greek-Syrian oppressors, they found only one small jar of oil, enough to keep the temple’s menorah burning for a single day. Miraculously, the oil lasted eight days, long enough to prepare new oil and rekindle the sacred light.

Christmas, celebrated by Christians around the world, marks the birth of Jesus Christ in Bethlehem more than 2,000 years ago. The scene of a child born in a manger has become a universal symbol of hope, love and peace. The Gospel of John refers to Jesus as “the light of the world,” a metaphor that resonates beautifully with Hanukkah’s story of the eternal flame.

Both holidays, at their core, celebrate the triumph of light over darkness, literal and spiritual. For Jews, it is the light of faith that endures persecution. For Christians, it is divine light that enters the world to guide humanity.

The symbolism of light is central to both holidays. In Jewish homes, the menorah (or hanukkiah) takes center stage. Each night, families light one additional candle until all eight glow brightly on the final evening, often accompanied by songs, prayers and laughter. The candles are placed in windows for all to see, a public declaration of faith and resilience.

At the same time, Christians illuminate Christmas trees, decorate homes with glowing stars and nativity scenes, and light candles in Advent wreaths leading up to Christmas Day. The twinkle of Christmas lights mirrors the radiance of Hanukkah candles, a shared affirmation that even in the coldest, darkest nights of winter, there is warmth and wonder to be found.

There is also something deeply human about the act of gathering around light. Fire and candles have long represented comfort, family and community. Whether it’s a menorah on the windowsill or a string of lights wrapped around a pine tree, both traditions remind us of our need for connection and meaning in the darkest season of the year.

Gift-giving has become a beloved custom of both holidays. Though Hanukkah is historically a modest holiday in Jewish tradition, the proximity of Christmas has influenced its modern observance, especially in America. Today, many Jewish families exchange small gifts over the eight nights, often emphasizing thoughtfulness over extravagance.

Christmas, of course, has long been associated with gift-giving, tracing back to the gifts of gold, frankincense and myrrh brought by the Magi to the Christ child. The tradition evolved over centuries, fueled by the legend of St. Nicholas, the fourth-century bishop known for his generosity to the poor. In modern times, the figure of Santa Claus has transformed this spirit into one of universal goodwill and joy.

While commercialism sometimes overshadows both holidays, at their best, the act of giving embodies compassion and empathy. A child choosing a present for a parent, a family donating to a charity, or a neighbor sharing a homemade treat all reflect the deeper message that the holidays are about kindness, not consumption.

If there’s one thing that truly unites both traditions, it’s the food. Hanukkah cuisine is rich with oil-based dishes, symbolizing the miracle of the long-lasting oil. The most famous are latkes, crispy potato pancakes fried to golden perfection and sufganiyot, jelly-filled doughnuts dusted with powdered sugar. Each bite celebrates not just history, but endurance and joy.

Christmas tables, on the other hand, are filled with comfort foods and family recipes passed down through generations. Roast meats, casseroles, cookies and cakes often take center stage, but the specifics vary widely by culture. Italians prepare seafood feasts on Christmas Eve, Germans bake spiced lebkuchen, and Latin American families enjoy tamales. In each case, food brings people together in a shared expression of gratitude and abundance.

Both holidays are deeply family-oriented. Hanukkah gatherings are often intimate, focused on home rituals, lighting candles, reciting blessings, playing dreidel and enjoying meals together. It’s a time to reconnect with heritage and history, to remember the resilience of the Jewish people.

Christmas, too, is about family and community. Churches are filled with carols, families exchange gifts under the tree, and communities come together to share meals and kindness. Even for those who are not religious, Christmas carries a cultural warmth that invites generosity and reflection.

Perhaps what makes these holidays so powerful is their shared message: even when the world feels dark, there is still reason to hope. Hanukkah celebrates the endurance of faith; Christmas celebrates the birth of love and hope. Both remind us that light is not merely something we see, it’s something we share.

In an increasingly interconnected world, December has become a month of interfaith awareness and cooperation. Schools, community centers and workplaces often recognize both Christmas and Hanukkah, allowing people to share traditions and learn from one another. This spirit fosters understanding across religious lines and builds bridges of respect.

In some cities, public menorah lightings take place beside community Christmas trees, sending a powerful message: our lights may differ in shape and story, but they shine for the same purpose, to bring people together.

Even in popular culture, the blending of traditions is visible. Television specials, holiday music and community events increasingly highlight the beauty of diverse celebrations. The season of light has become a season of mutual appreciation, where faith is celebrated rather than divided.

At the heart of both Hanukkah and Christmas lies a promise: that even in the darkest of times, light endures. The menorah’s glow reminds Jews of the resilience of their ancestors and the ongoing miracle of survival. The Christmas star reminds Christians of divine guidance and love that entered the world in humility.

In a world often shadowed by conflict, uncertainty and loss, these stories offer timeless comfort. They encourage us to look for light not only in our traditions but also in each other.

When the nights grow long and the air grows cold, people instinctively turn to light, to candles, to fires, to faith. December’s holidays, whether celebrated in a synagogue or a church, around a menorah or beneath a tree, tell us the same truth: the smallest light can chase away great darkness.

Though Hanukkah and Christmas stem from different faiths, their messages harmonize beautifully. Both call for gratitude, compassion, and hope. Both center around family, tradition and generosity. And both invite us to share our light with others.

So, when December arrives and homes sparkle with menorahs and Christmas trees alike, it is not a contradiction, it’s a chorus of lights, each one telling a story of faith and renewal. Whether you say Merry Christmas or Happy Hanukkah, you are celebrating the same essential truth: that love, faith and light are what make the world bright again.

Happy Holidays.

Michael Kossove is a frequent contributor to the River Reporter. He is  professor emeritus and adjunct professor of microbiology, Touro University, School of Health Sciences, and lives in Sullivan County, NY.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here