32 °F
October 27, 2016
River Reporter Facebook pageTRR TwitterRSS Search

Thousands of comments expected on SGEIS; parties weigh in on comment period

Meanwhile, some groups have begun to comment on the substance of the SGEIS. Catskill Mountainkeeper, for instance, said the SGEIS does not include an adequate health assessment of drilling and hydraulic fracturing. A statement on their website said, “The governor is acting like fracking is a done deal. Albany insiders tell us that fracking revenues are being put in the 2012 budget. This, and the unwillingness to extend the comment period to at least 180 days and review health impacts, makes it look like the hearing process is to satisfy appearances only.”

DEC plans to hold four public hearings during the comment period for the SGEIS in November. The meetings will be held in counties in the Marcellus Shale area, as well as New York City. Dates and locations will be announced shortly.

Some people would have drilled in 2008, sans sGEIS

The folks who call all study and comment a stalling tactic, never admitted to problems, especially substantial ones, back in 2008 when the Paterson administration called for a supplement to the 1992 GEIS.

Those drill baby drillers were wrong then, and they are wrong now. The industry has been forced to solve problems that it, and its supporters, never admitted existed in the first place.

The initial sGEIS has been substantially altered as a result of the public review and comment. This is how it should be.

Laura Legere, writing in the Scranton Times Tribune, states a PA DEP statistic that there were 65 confirmed cases of methane migration, by its own count, due to faulty casing and cement jobs, just within the first 8 months of 2011, in PA. This figure is one more than recorded in all of 2010.

Compare this to Aubrey McClendon getting up at the industry pow wow love fest in Philadelphia recently, and stating that all gas migration problems related to casing and cement failures have been solved by the industry, and it is therefore, no longer a threat to the population!

What PA DEP is referring to are immediate failures, due to shoddy workmanship, or inherently faulty geology, in the Appalachian Basin. This is a geology that is not required to be mapped prior to drilling, and there are no restrictions as to drilling within this "faulty" geology.

What is not even considered is the high failure rate of cement casing in gas and oil wells over a given 15 year period. Wait until those studies, and results, start manifesting themselves.

The NY TIMES is a pro business newspaper, and even it calls for extreme caution before permitting.

I would add a note to my NWPOA neighbors, that their company, Hess Corp, was cited by PA DEP, in the Legere article, for allowing methane migration, through faulty casing, on one of the first wells it has drilled in Wayne County (the Davidson well in Scott Township). Besides Hess, the article also lists Chesapeake, Exco, Williams, and XTO as offenders.

I thought Cabot was supposed to be the only incompetent, "bad actor"? No, this is inherent to the simple act of drilling and casing, especially in the Appalachian Basin.

Comment period is unecessary

The regulations the DEC have developed should stand as written and permits should be issued NOW! The citizens of NY voted for the people running our state. They appointed people to head our departments, like the DEC. Those departments HIRE qualified personnel to perform the duties necessary. I'm sure the Commissioner of the DEC, Joe Martens, who led the OSI for 16 yrs and is one of the most environmentally conscious people around has complete confidence in his staff, why then do we need to hear from the butcher, the baker, and the candlestick maker? People can send comments whenever they want, forever, there's no reason other than politics to wait for more crackpot NIMBY whining.

This is known as a stalling tactic.

Obstructionists learn it at the mothers' knees.