THE RIVER REPORTER CLIMATE CHALLENGE
Business carbon impact worksheet   Household carbon impact worksheet






Living in gasland

Glen Spey’s Homestead School visits Dimock

By SANDY LONG

DIMOCK, PA — William Farnelli would like to move to Australia because he’s heard there isn’t any gas drilling there. That’s what the fifth-grader told a student from The Homestead School in Glen Spey, NY who traveled with fellow fourth through sixth graders to Dimock for a firsthand look at what it’s like to live where natural gas exploration is taking place.

The experience appeared to be a sobering one for those who got to glimpse the landscape of rolling hills blanketed in fall foliage and studded with drilling rigs and well pads next to houses and barns. It prompted the question—have you ever thought of moving?—that led to William’s quietly voiced answer.

With his sister Rachel, a third-grader, at his side, the wide-eyed pair and their mother, Pat, described the ways in which drilling activities have changed their lives over the past three years. They live on bottled water to avoid the nausea and cramps that come if they drink their well water. They must purchase what they consume and continue to bathe in their well water while suffering rashes, dizziness and headaches.

The chronic noise of the trucks, which continues through the night, and the constant light make it hard to sleep. And while it would be a relief to slip away to somewhere else, Pat says it’s not likely anyone will want to buy their house.

The community continues to divide, as Cabot Oil and Gas Corporation and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection battle over the proposed solution to install an $11.8 million water main. The decision has prompted the formation of Enough Already, a local group of business and homeowners opposed to the pipeline.

The day began at Julie and Craig Sautner’s home on Carter Road, where students learned how the couple copes with the loss of their water well to contamination that the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection traces to nearby drilling operations at Cabot sites.

The group then paid a visit to Congressman Chris Carney’s home approximately a mile away, where they introduced themselves to Mrs. Carney and left one of their Green Power Alliance t-shirts, along with a promise to follow up with letters to the congressman about their experience and concerns.

Continuing along the rural roads, the students observed cleared acreage where well pads, drill rigs and gathering lines are being stitched into the fabric of farmland and neighborhoods. A stop at the local K-12 school revealed a drilling rig rising into the horizon near the school track.

Later, perched on the lawn of a local church, speakers attempted to shout their messages over the chronic grinding drone of heavy trucks hauling excavation materials, residual waste water and tanks filled with clean water for some homeowners.

Before leaving, the Homestead students wanted William and Rachel to know that they’re not alone and gave them each a t-shirt. “Now you can be part of the Green Power Alliance,” they said.

For more information, contact Peter Comstock, head of school and Green Power Alliance advisor at 845/856-6359. Visit riverreporter.blogspot.com to read some responses to the Dimock experience submitted by those on the trip.

TRR photo by Sandy Long
Julie Sautner receives gifts of local organic produce and other items from the students. In the background is a pipe installed in the home’s front yard to vent methane from the Sautners’ contaminated water well. Students toured a water treatment system installed by Cabot in the Sautner’s basement, which failed to solve the problem and now sits idle. Currently, they receive a daily delivery of water from an armed supplier provided by Cabot. Storage requires a large water buffalo that consumes space in their garage and incurs additional heating costs to prevent the water from freezing. (Click for larger version)
TRR photo by Sandy Long
Grace Lutfy, at center left, and her sister Sophie, right, listen as Julie Sautner describes her situation in Dimock. Two years ago, the Lutfys participated in a trip taken by the Homestead School to Appalachia to learn about the mountaintop removal occurring there as a result of coal mining. Comparing the two experiences, Grace said, “It’s sad to see this type of thing again. They know that they’re polluting water and air; they know that they’re destroying land, and yet they keep going through with it. Most of it seems to do with money. It’s silly that people are willing to ruin such wonderful things for it.” (Click for larger version)
TRR photo by Sandy Long
Homestead School students line up at the home of PA Congressman Chris Carney in Dimock, PA. In early 2008, the students attended a town meeting in Milford, PA hosted by Carney. Student Grace Lutfy presented her first slide show about mountaintop removal. (See www.riverreporter.com/issues/08-03-27/head1-cleanwater.html). “We asked him to sign the Clean Water Protection Act and he said, ‘There’s some things I have to look at, but I’ll get back to you.’ We respected that, because there are other sides to the story,” said Lutfy. “Well, it’s been nearly three years and we’re still waiting. We’ve made phone calls and sent letters. What’s even stranger is, he lives here, in the middle of it all, so why wouldn’t he want to protect his own water for his family? It’s sad that his neighbors, the Sautners, have to go through what they’re going through.” (Click for larger version)
TRR photos by Sandy Long
The evolving landscape of Dimock is a sometimes jarring juxtaposition of rural living and industrial development is seen here and in the three photos below. (Click for larger version)
(Click for larger version)
(Click for larger version)
(Click for larger version)
TRR photo by Sandy Long
The Sautners hold aloft a bottle of their contaminated well water and bottles of fresh water brought from New York by the children. The students also presented the Sautners with a check for $300. (Click for larger version)