|
Quality
Surveys
Every year
the gods over at Agoura Hills speak and the auto manufacturers quake
in their boots. I'm talking about the research and survey firm J.D.
Power and Associates. They publish The Power Report, a monthly newsletter
targeted towards the auto industry. Besides the usual business oriented
articles, the company also conducts a number of surveys and their
best known one is the J.D. Power and Associates survey of initial
vehicle quality.
Carmakers often
use the results of this survey in their advertising to point out
how "good" their cars are and indeed, there are some car buyers
who place great value on such information. Personally, I believe
that at best, this survey and others like it highlight overall trends
more than anything else. If you look closely, there are inconsistencies.
For example, I know that many cars are built on the same assembly
line (Plymouth Neon/Dodge Neon, Geo Prizm/Toyota Corolla, all the
Chrysler/Dodge/Plymouth minivans, Chevrolet/Oldsmobile/Pontiac minivans
and others) yet they get different results. Why does the Toyota
Corolla rank ninth while the identical Chevrolet Prism comes in
at number 26? Are the Corollas built any different than the Prizms?
No, they aren't-the difference has to do with the people who buy
them and no survey takes that into account.
Anyway, listed
below are the results of the 2000 survey. Take them with a grain
of salt.
The 2000 problem
scores show the average number of customer-reported problems within
the first three months of ownership per 100 vehicles, covering 135
specific problem areas. The industry average was 154 problems.
|
RANK
MAKE 2000 PROBLEMS
|
| 1. |
Lexus
LS 400 |
71 |
| 2. |
Acura
RL |
81 |
| 3. |
Lexus
ES 300 |
84 |
| 3. |
Acura
TL |
84 |
| 5. |
Mercedes-Benz
SL-Class+ |
85 |
| 6. |
Lexus
GS Sedan |
88 |
| 7. |
Porsche
911 |
93 |
| 8. |
Jaguar
XK8 |
95 |
| 9. |
Toyota
Avalon |
97 |
| 9. |
Toyota
Corolla |
97 |
| 9. |
Toyota
Camry |
97 |
| 12. |
Infiniti
I30 |
98 |
| 13. |
Lexus
LX 470 |
100 |
| 14. |
Mercedes-Benz
S-Class |
101 |
| 15. |
Jaguar
XJ |
103 |
| 15. |
BMW 5
Series |
103 |
| 17. |
Honda
S2000 |
104 |
| 18. |
Mercedes-Benz
E-Class |
105 |
| 19. |
Infiniti
QX4 |
106 |
| 20. |
Toyota
Land Cruiser |
108 |
| 21. |
BMW 7
Series |
109 |
| 22. |
Toyota
Sienna |
111 |
| 23. |
Nissan
Maxima |
112 |
| 24. |
Chevrolet
Corvette |
113 |
| 24. |
Honda
Accord |
113 |
| 26. |
Chevrolet
Prizm |
114 |
| 27. |
BMW 3
Series |
115 |
| 27. |
Audi A8+ |
115 |
| 29. |
Saab
9-5 |
118 |
| 29. |
Plymouth
Breeze |
118 |
| 31. |
Cadillac
DeVille |
119 |
| 32. |
Volvo
S70 |
120 |
| 32. |
Volvo
V70 |
120 |
| 34. |
Buick
Regal |
121 |
| 35. |
Toyota
Tundra |
122 |
| 35. |
Lexus
RX 300 |
122 |
| 36. |
Mercedes-Benz
SLK |
123 |
| 37. |
Buick
LeSabre |
124 |
| 37. |
Mercedes-Benz
CLK-Class |
124 |
| 39. |
Nissan
Pathfinder |
125 |
| 39. |
Honda
CR-V |
125 |
| 39. |
Lincoln
Town Car |
125 |
| 39. |
Dodge
Intrepid |
125 |
| 43. |
Mercury
Grand Marquis |
126 |
| 44. |
Lincoln
Navigator |
127 |
| 45. |
Plymouth
Voyager |
128 |
| 45. |
Oldsmobile
Intrigue |
128 |
| 47. |
Mitsubishi
Mirage |
129 |
| 47. |
Mercury
Mountaineer |
129 |
| 49. |
Acura
Integra |
130 |
| 49. |
Mazda
626 |
130 |
| 51. |
Chrysler
Concorde |
132 |
| 51. |
Ford F-150
Light Duty |
132 |
| 53. |
Honda
Civic |
133 |
| 53. |
Chevrolet
Malibu |
133 |
| 55. |
Lincoln
Continental |
134 |
| 55. |
Toyota
RAV4 |
134 |
| 57. |
Dodge
Stratus |
136 |
| 58. |
Audi A4
|
137 |
| 58. |
Buick
Park Avenue |
137 |
| 60. |
Buick
Century |
138 |
| 60. |
Ford Crown
Victoria |
138 |
| 62. |
Chrysler
LHS |
139 |
| 62. |
Ford Expedition
|
139 |
| 62. |
Chevrolet
Monte Carlo |
139 |
| 65. |
Porsche
Boxster |
140 |
| 65. |
Toyota
4Runner |
140 |
| 67. |
Audi A6
|
141 |
| 67. |
Mercedes-Benz
C-Class |
141 |
| 67. |
Mazda
B-Series |
141 |
| 70. |
Honda
Prelude |
142 |
| 71. |
Chrysler
Cirrus |
143 |
| 72. |
Chevrolet
Impala |
144 |
| 73. |
Dodge
Neon |
146 |
| 74. |
Mercury
Sable |
147 |
| 74. |
Dodge
Caravan |
147 |
| 74. |
Saturn
SL |
147 |
| 74. |
Land
Rover Range Rover+ |
147 |
| 78. |
Nissan
Altima |
148 |
| 78. |
Saturn
SW |
148 |
| 80. |
Mazda
Millenia |
149 |
| 80. |
Honda
Odyssey |
149 |
| 82. |
Cadillac
Eldorado |
150 |
| 82. |
Ford
Taurus |
150 |
| 82. |
Mazda
Protege |
150 |
| 85. |
Ford Econoline
|
151 |
| 85. |
Infiniti
G20 |
151 |
| 86. |
BMW Z3
|
152 |
| 87. |
Chrysler
Town & Country |
154 |
| 87. |
Saab 9-3
|
154 |
| 87. |
Chrysler
300M |
154 |
| 90. |
Pontiac
Grand Prix |
155 |
| 91. |
GMC Sonoma
|
154 |
| 91. |
Jaguar
S-Type |
154 |
|
INDUSTRY
AVERAGE |
154 |
| 93. |
Ford F-250
Super Duty |
155 |
| 93. |
Oldsmobile
Alero |
155 |
| 93. |
Plymouth
Neon |
155 |
| 96. |
Mitsubishi
Diamante |
156 |
| 96. |
Volvo
S80 |
156 |
| 96. |
Pontiac
Grand Am |
156 |
| 99. |
Chevrolet
S-10 Pickup |
157 |
| 100. |
Cadillac
Catera+ |
159 |
| 101. |
Hyundai
Sonata |
160 |
| 101. |
Daewoo
Nubira+ |
160 |
| 103. |
Chevrolet
Suburban |
161 |
| 104. |
Honda
Passport |
162 |
| 104. |
Dodge
Avenger |
162 |
| 104. |
Mercury
Mystique |
162 |
|
104.
|
Mitsubishi
Montero Sport |
162 |
| 108. |
Volkswagen
Passat |
163 |
| 108. |
Toyota
Echo |
163 |
| 108. |
Ford Ranger
|
163 |
| 108. |
Lincoln
LS |
163 |
| 112. |
Chevrolet
Cavalier |
164 |
| 113. |
GMC Jimmy
|
165 |
| 114. |
Mitsubishi
Galant |
167 |
| 114. |
Oldsmobile
Silhouette |
167 |
| 114. |
Pontiac
Firebird |
167 |
| 114. |
Chevrolet
Camaro |
167 |
| 118. |
Volvo
V40 |
169 |
| 118. |
Toyota
Tacoma |
169 |
| 118. |
Cadillac
Seville |
169 |
| 121. |
Audi TT
|
170 |
| 122. |
Chrysler
Sebring JX convertible |
171 |
| 123. |
Pontiac
Sunfire |
172 |
| 123. |
Saturn
SC |
172 |
| 123. |
Ford Mustang
|
172 |
| 123. |
Volkswagen
New Beetle |
172 |
| 127. |
Hyundai
Accent |
173 |
| 127. |
Toyota
Celica |
173 |
| 127. |
Dodge
Durango |
173 |
| 130. |
GMC Yukon
XL (Suburban) |
174 |
| 131. |
Chevrolet
Blazer |
176 |
| 131. |
Ford Focus
|
176 |
| 133. |
Volvo
S40 |
177 |
| 133. |
Mitsubishi
Eclipse |
177 |
| 135. |
Chevrolet
Silverado 1500/2500 |
179 |
| 135. |
Mazda
MPV |
179 |
| 135. |
Nissan
Frontier |
179 |
| 135. |
Pontiac
Bonneville |
179 |
| 139. |
Ford Explorer |
180 |
| 140. |
Mercury
Villager |
181 |
| 141. |
Jeep Grand
Cherokee |
182 |
| 142. |
Cadillac
Escalade |
183 |
| 143. |
GMC Sierra
1500/2500 |
184 |
| 143. |
Oldsmobile
Bravada |
184 |
| 143. |
Chrysler
Sebring coupe |
184 |
| 143. |
Ford
Escort ZX2 |
184 |
| 143. |
Mercury
Cougar |
184 |
| 148. |
Subaru
Legacy |
185 |
| 148. |
Daewoo
Leganza |
185 |
| 148. |
GMC Savana+
|
185 |
| 148. |
Saturn
LS |
185 |
| 152. |
GMC Yukon
(GMT400) |
186 |
| 153. |
Volkswagen
Golf |
187 |
| 154. |
Nissan
Quest |
189 |
| 154. |
Chevrolet
Metro |
189 |
| 156. |
GMC Safari
|
191 |
| 157. |
Jeep Cherokee
|
192 |
| 157. |
Subaru
Forester |
192 |
| 159. |
Nissan
Xterra |
193 |
| 160. |
Dodge
Ram Pickup 1500 |
197 |
| 160. |
Ford Contour
|
197 |
| 162. |
Dodge
Ram Van |
198 |
| 163. |
Ford Windstar
|
199 |
| 164. |
Volkswagen
GTI |
200 |
| 164. |
Isuzu
Rodeo+ |
200 |
| 164. |
Mercedes-Benz
M-Class |
200 |
| 167. |
Jeep Wrangler |
201 |
| 167. |
Ford Excursion
|
201 |
| 169. |
Chevrolet
Venture |
202 |
| 170. |
Dodge
Dakota |
203 |
| 171. |
Subaru
Impreza |
204 |
| 172. |
Subaru
Outback Sdn/Wgn |
206 |
| 173. |
Subaru
Outback Sport |
207 |
| 173. |
Pontiac
Montana |
207 |
| 173. |
Suzuki
Esteem |
207 |
| 176. |
Land Rover
Discovery Series II |
208 |
| 177. |
Chevrolet
Tracker |
209 |
| 178. |
Mitsubishi
Montero+ |
210 |
| 179. |
Hyundai
Elantra |
212 |
| 180. |
Saturn
LW |
214 |
| 180. |
Volvo
C70 |
214 |
| 182. |
Chevrolet
Express |
215 |
| 183. |
Chevrolet
Astro |
218 |
| 184. |
Chevrolet
Tahoe (GMT400) |
226 |
| 185. |
Kia Sephia
|
227 |
| 186. |
Volkswagen
Cabrio |
230 |
| 187. |
Volkswagen
Jetta |
234 |
| 188. |
Suzuki
Vitara/Grand Vitara |
236 |
| 189. |
Hyundai
Tiburon |
270 |
| 190. |
Daewoo
Lanos+ |
293 |
| 191. |
Kia Sportage |
298 |
|
|
|