Don't
Ask Me Why
By Elliot
Gurian
Since I have
never before included a disclaimer in our bi-weekly get-togethers,
I am hereby breaking new ground. If any IRS agent or other government
employee reads this, please be aware that this column may contain
fiction and names have been changed to protect...me.
Ed Green, the
financial planner friend that I introduced you to a couple of months
ago, was explaining to me what he does when a client needs more
time to file a tax return. In April, you can automatically get four
more months - until August 15 - by simply sending in a form. But,
what if you need even more time? Well, he told me that you file
another form for two more months, but the second extension requires
an explanation acceptable to the IRS. According to IRS instructions,
you must "have a good reason why the first four months were not
enough."
In explaining
to me what is or is not acceptable, he used some examples that have
worked for him. For a family that changed their residence during
the year "We need more time because we misplaced our tax records
during our move" has always done the job. After very wet seasons,
he has employed "Our records were destroyed when our basement was
flooded. We are currently in the process of reconstructing them."
I don't know about you, but I'm going to put on my hip boots.
If someone
is heavily into the stock market, Ed has found that "Additional
time is required to determine the proper treatment of various capital
transactions" is very effective. What exactly does all that mean?
Basically, it says that we have no good reason on earth to not be
ready.
Consider two
of Ed's all time favorites: "Various complicated business transactions
during the year need additional analysis" and "We have either misplaced
or have never received some important tax documentation. Our bank
is currently providing us with duplicates." Do you have a clear
picture by now? Although the IRS says they require a legitimate,
reasonable excuse, it is apparent that nobody actually reads those
forms. I wonder what would happen if some obviously outrageous reasons
started appearing. They might actually be forced to evaluate each
one.
Younger taxpayers
might, with imagination typical of a child, try "My dog ate my W-2
form," "I couldn't find my pencil" or "There was a really good show
on TV that I couldn't miss." Unless their paperwork crosses the
desk of an extremely young IRS employee, they are going to be sent
to bed without their dinner.
Current TV
viewers with imagination could hope to have their reason considered
by someone who does not watch much of today's boob tube fare. Consider
"I just got home from the islands. I was on Survivor..." On the
other hand, they might hope for a late night fan to rule on "Ramona
on the Psychic Hotline told me that this was not a good time to
do my taxes." Quiz show fans might even have to use a lifeline.
Ed's client
Skip Van Winkle may have tried "My Uncle Rip invited me to his place
in the Catskills for a vacation and for some bowling. Then he suggested
that we take a nap... The rest is history." And, Ishmael from New
England might have done well with "Our captain was going to do my
taxes, but he had a whaling mishap."
Do you think
that the IRS is gullible? As an organization, I suppose it isn't,
but the individuals within it might well be. It is questionable
that any would give a pass to someone who tried "I am being new
to your country and am not knowing your laws about taxes." Another
that wouldn't fly is "I was watching a ball game at Shea Stadium
and Mike Piazza knocked me out with a home run ball."
Ed is also
quite sure that there is no one who would fall for excuses claiming
alien abductions, throwing out the tax forms with the Publishers'
Clearing House envelope or a claim that you are not good with numbers.
Neither will they buy your assertion that your paperwork was shipped
to you by way of the Russian submarine squad. The old "I came down
with an upset stomach after trying out for the Olympic pie-eating
team" is sure to be doomed for failure.
Famous people
are certainly not immune to procrastination. If the Irish playwright,
Samuel Beckett was required to file taxes in the United States,
chances are his request for more time would be justified by "Give
me a little more time. I'm almost ready. I'm waiting for Godot."
Lewis F. Muir and L. Wolfe Gilbert might have explained their situation
with "We were waitin' on the levee, waitin' for the Robert E. Lee."
Some celebrities have procrastination built into their name. Consider
singer/songwriter Tom Waits or, perhaps, the Dad on "the Waltons,"
Ralph Waite.
Honesty is
always the best policy, even when dealing with the IRS, but it can't
hurt to embellish the truth with interesting and supportive details.
After all, you are appealing to a human being behind a desk who
has one of the most boring jobs in the world. The compassionate
thing to do might be to provide a few laughs. So, next year, try
"I didn't think I had to file since I did it last year" or "I forgot."
In his tax
practice, Ed Green has never had a request for additional time rejected
by the IRS. He strives for reasonableness and sense when he files.
But that is so unlike the way I know him to be. Don't ask me why
he has done so little to brighten the humdrum lives of IRS paper-pushers.
Maybe he will turn over a new leaf in the new millennium.
|