By DAVID HULSE
MONTICELLO — Rep. Maurice Hinchey says a state time frame that
would see a decade or more pass before Route 17 actually becomes
Interstate 86 is unacceptable and he wants area residents to see
that their state legislators get the message.
Hinchey said the effort to make the highway part of the federal
system was initiated in Congress and state officials have been "dragged
along kicking and screaming," from the beginning. Now-needed-design
changes and repairs that would allow the designation in five to
six years have been given a low priority in Albany, while state
officials sit on billions of federal highway dollars, Hinchey said.
Hinchey (D-26) called a meeting at the Sullivan County Government
Center on Monday to implore county residents to write and lobby
their representatives in Albany to include $30 million in planning
and engineering money in this year’s state budget for upgrading
the highway to interstate standards. He said it was a matter of
economic common sense and funding necessity.
The congressman provided numbers to back his claims. The state
has estimated a $550 million total cost for various upgrades and
design changes along the 204-mile section of Route 17 between Broome
County and Harriman— western portions of the highway already are
designated as interstate highway. The state is estimating eight
to 12 years for the work.
But Hinchey said the delay is unnecessary as well as impractical.
Aside from economic losses, New York stands to lose additional federal
grant funding if plans for the upgrade are not done in three years.
Quoting a recent consultant’s study Hinchey said that the new highway
would have a $3.2 billion impact over 20 years, if competed in eight
years. Additionally, the State of New York stands to gain approximately
$82 million through increased sales tax revenue. By delaying the
designation, the study found that $711 million in economic development
growth would be forfeited and the state would stand to lose $18.6
million in additional sales tax revenues.
The state’s timeliness could also impact available funding, he
said. Work on I-86 must be included in the state Department of Transportation’s
five-year plan, if funding schedules are to be met. New federal
transportation grants under so-called "TEA-21" legislation
will provide $8.2 billion in federal money in the next three years,
but if plans are not prepared within that time, federal dollars
will go back to Washington, he warned.
A failure to budget this work when the federal government is funding
all but a fraction of the cost is "poor management, poor government,"
he said. New York "has to get off its duff to get the design
work done," Hinchey said.
Funding $550 million may sound like massive amounts, but the figure
is only some seven percent of the federal money New York will be
receiving, Hinchey said. "Clearly, the money is there to do
it," he said.
Hinchey, a Democrat, said "the state is not on the ball on
this" and intimated that transportation decisions were being
made "largely" by Republican leaders in Albany, but he
said, "they can be changed. [Route 17] can be given a higher
priority."
The new interstate would parallel I-90, the east/west Thruway,
whose tolls could suffer from new competition, but Hinchey said
he saw no conflict in that for state officials. "It would take
growing traffic pressure off (north/south Thruway) I-87and provide
better traffic safety," he said.
Still, the designation has its critics. Ken Saltzman, owner of
the Memories, an antique and furniture store in Parksville, said
he would lose his unique position of being a direct pull-off from
Route 17. He had other concerns. "If you were talking rail
service, I would said ‘this guy’s a messiah.’" Saltzman said.
Hinchey was adamant. "I think the argument for I-86 is irrefutable.
The state delegation has to make it the number-one priority for
the southern tier, because it is. Nothing anyone else could do even
rises close to the level of this project. We need to promote it,"
he said.
Hinchey said lobbying, letters and calls to local state legislators
and the leaders in the Assembly and Senate were needed to get the
budget changes before the legal, if not likely state budget preparation
deadline of April 1.
The joint Government Affairs Committee of the Partnership for Economic
Development and Sullivan County Chamber of Commerce, under the leadership
of Anna Niemann of Cooper and Niemann, CPA’s, are sponsoring the
annual lobbying bus trip for Small Business Day in Albany on March
28. Contact Niemann at 914/796-1800, Michael J. Sullivan at 794-1110
or Jacquie Leventoff at 794-2211 for ticket information.